Gooey Butter Cake Cookies

Gooey Butter Cake Cookies

Gooey butter cake is a staple to St. Louis. It's like a cakey brownie. It has a harder bottom layer and a denser, but chewy top layer. When I first visited Tyler in St. Louis in 2013, it was a mission of mine to find some of the best places for us to eat at. He was in grad school and eating out wasn’t always an option on his budget. But it was his birthday and we needed to celebrate. I found this place online called Park Avenue Coffee Roasters. They sell bake and sell Ann & Allen’s Gooey Butter Cake.

They don’t just sell regular vanilla flavor, they make basically any flavor you can think of and then some. I loved this little cozy coffee shop, where we could sit and try this delicious treat for the first time. I believe our first flavors were traditional (yellow cake/vanilla) and cinnamon roll (seasonal). But they also have red velvet, chocolate chip cookie dough, pumpkin spice, and so much more.

So, of course when we went back with his whole family in 2014 we ordered almost everything on the menu and between the six of us we were able to try them all! It was such a fun experience. And when I moved to St. Louis in 2015, it was always a fun place to take friends and family to try this St. Louis classic.

Table of Contents

And after moving to St. Louis, I began to realize that most St. Louis Natives make their own version of Gooey Butter Cake. Whether it’s a recipe from their favorite restaurant, grandma’s own special recipe, or even a recipe from a local paper or magazine…everyone had a recipe at the ready. I decided to try making my own referencing a few recipes from coworkers and online. Then, I decided that I wanted to make them into cookies. I had done it with crinkle cookies in the past using a cake mix, why not these? The only real difference is using the additional butter and cream cheese instead of oil.

I started making them 100% from scratch. I thought I preferred from scratch so I could feel like they were 100% homemade. Then, in a hurry one day I used box mix…and man, they were still delicious and so much easier. I cut my prep time in half, at least! And you know what, you’re still making them from scratch. They are homemade!  

And now that we’re back in California after spending four years in St. Louis, experiencing so much amazing food, these gooey butter cookies will always be something I take away from my time there. I was so lucky to be able to try so many amazing things in my time there. Some STL staples weren’t for me…like Imo’s and toasted ravioli. But gooey butter cake (and of course frozen custard) will always hold a special place in my heart.

These gooey butter cookies are a great way to get that gooey butter cake taste, but in a simple cookie! They are wonderful for any celebration, can be customized, and even used in a beautiful holiday cookie box!

Gooey Butter Cake Cookies with Cake Mix

Using cake mix takes the stress out of finding/having the right ingredients, but is also a great time saver! And for those non-bakers, this recipe is just a few steps easier. You’re still making something unique and different, so don’t think that this is cheating or not baking from scratch, you still are!

I used to make these and my chocolate crinkle cookies all from scratch, however, I know that not everyone carries these ingredients in their houses, so I've posted recipes using cake mixes! Of course, you can simply replace those mixes with your own favorite dry cake mix ingredients. Which means these are easy to make gluten free as well.

Different Flavors of Gooey Butter Cake Cookies

An easy way to customize the flavors for these is to simply use a different flavor cake mix. It’s seriously that easy. You can use chocolate, red velvet, whatever floats your boat. Some will spread more than others just by their other ingredients. But, it’s fun to play with them and see what you can make. The most important part to these is the cream cheese, butter, and coating in powdered sugar.

Some other fun ways to customize these cookies is to add peppermint pieces to the powdered sugar. Just another fun way to add holiday spirit into your cookies. Or change the flavoring of the extract. For example, to make these “funfetti” just add butter extract and 1-2 tablespoon of sprinkles to the batter. And voila, you’ve done it!

Gooey Butter Christmas Cookies

Like I mentioned above, you can completely customize these. A few ways I like to do that is for the holidays. I like to add peppermint pieces to my powdered sugar before rolling the dough in it. Or you can make the cookies using a chocolate batter and use peppermint extract there as well. Completely customizable and perfect for the holidays!

Gooey Butter Cake Cookie Recipe

Yellow Cake Mix Cookies Ingredients

• 1 box of yellow cake mix (or your favorite yellow cake recipe sans wet ingredients)
• ½ cup butter (softened)
• 8 oz cream cheese (room temperature)
• 1 egg
• ¼ teaspoon vanilla extract
• 1 cup powdered sugar
• crushed peppermint, optional

How to make Gooey Butter Cookies

1. Using an electric mixer, combine the butter, cream cheese, egg, and vanilla until light and fluffy.
2. Stir in the cake mix until the dough becomes smooth and thoroughly combined. Cover your bowl and place the dough in the refrigerator to chill for 30 minutes.
3. Place your powdered sugar into a separate bowl.
4. After your dough has chilled, preheat your oven to 350° F.
5. Scoop a spoonful of dough into your hands and roll into a ball. Drop a few of the dough balls into the powdered sugar and toss to coat. Optional to now add in some crushed peppermint candies or sprinkles at this time to your powdered sugar.
6. Place the dough balls onto an ungreased cookie sheet and bake for 12 minutes.
7. Cool and enjoy!

FAQs on Gooey Butter Cake Cookies

Other Cookie Recipes to Try

• Molasses Cookies
• Holiday Cookie Box
• Perfect Chocolate Chip Cookies
• Graham Cracker Crumble Soft Butter Cookies
• Double Chocolate Chunk Cookies
• Snickerdoodles
• Oatmeal Cookies
• Lucky Charms Cookies

Love this Recipe?

Did you make this recipe and just love it? Awesome! If you have a quick minute and could leave a star rating and comment below, I would appreciate the support and knowing your feedback! And if you’re over on Instagram, be sure to tag me in your photos!